Sunday, September 12, 2010

Union Bullshit

Trade Union leaders failing to break the habit of a life time by talking total fucking bollocks:
TUC chief Brendan Barber has said the public will not accept large-scale spending cuts, as trade unions gather in Manchester.
They will accept them, I believe, because public spending has become synonymous with waste. If the government trims the unproductive parts of its operations, it will not adversely affect how the public live their lives but will allow for, in the longer-term, populist measures such as tax cuts.
Mr Barber said unions would reach out to the wider community to form a "progressive alliance" to make the case for alternatives to spending cuts.
Oh, Jesus titty-fucking Christ, it's that word again - "progressive". And it is being completely misused here. What Barber wants to form is, by definition, a "conservative alliance" - he wishes to conserve the status quo. Which is fine - he can go away and do that to his heart's content. But don't lie about it - you're being conservative, Barber. And anyone with any intellect won't ally themselves with you because you're attempting to conserve an unsustainable and ultimately regressive status quo.
RMT union leader Bob Crow called for a campaign of "civil disobedience" in protest at spending cuts.
Well, I want to call for a campaign of "civil disobedience" against Bob Crow. And after the tube strikes, I think a campaign against him will be far more popular than a campaign against spending cuts.

I have no issue with the Trade Unions campaigning in the best interests of their members - hell, that's what they're for. But campaigning for the government to continue with the levels of spending that are running the risk of bankrupting this country is not in the interests of their members, and certainly isn't in the interests of the country as a whole.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, August 26, 2010

Left-Wing Semantics

Daniel Hannan clearly understands the semantics of modern politics. Or, to put it another way, the semantic distortions of the statist left:
Still, one has to admire the way in which Lefties have captured the word “fair”. Any reduction of state spending must, by definition, mainly affect those who draw income from the state, just as any tax-cut must, by definition, favour those who are paying tax. Therefore, by a brilliant semantic shift, it is “unfair” not to carry on expanding the state forever.
Abso-fucking-lutely. The same is true with the word progressive, as I seem to endlessly be banging on about. To be "progressive" and "fair" in the language of modern Britain seems to require a commitment to state-expansion. Even though there is nothing progressive or fair about that expansion; it simply leads to the slow strangulation of freedom and responsibility in this country.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

3 Non-News Stories

Today is one of those special days where nearly every "news" story makes me shrug in broad apathy. Let's take a look at some of the highlights:

Think-tank states a Tory budget is not progressive: So the fuck what? You could probably find another Think Tank that says precisely the opposite. Hell, you could probably find one that sees the budget as the best thing that has ever happened to anyone ever, and another one that thinks precisely the opposite. It is all meaningless anyway, since the word progressive means nothing. Literally, nothing. It is a word that lefties use as a shorthand for "we like this", nothing more. So just imagine that - left-wingers not liking the Tories. Crazy, eh?

Woman puts cat in bin: Ok, that was a pretty shitty thing to do, but let's keep our sense of perspective here, people. Its a cat. It is ok. Basically, this story is saying that people are shitty and cruel sometimes. But there are much better examples of that in human history. The 1994 Rwandan genocide would be a good example. As would the Beslan school massacre. As would... well, you get the point.

John Cruddas backs David Miliband for Labour Leader: So one charisma bypass backs another charisma bypass in the barely fought race to be the person to lose the next election for the Labour party. How can this really be a news story? The only possible newsworthy outcome of this union of non-entities would be if these two people met in the same room and quite literally sucked all the life out of it through the tedium created by their utterly unhistoric meeting.

Today is yet another indictment of the 24/7 news cycle, where tedium is spun into being news despite not really being interesting on any level.

Labels: , , , ,

Let's actually have ideology in politics

Chuntering noisemonkey Ed Balls on the "regressive" Coalition:
“The government’s ideological assault on our welfare state and public services is not simply economic vandalism, I fear it will damage the very fabric of our society too."
I have little interest in what Balls has to say - I'm tired of listening to his vapid and deeply predictable assaults on the Tories and/or the Lib Dems. You could replace Balls with a basic programme designed to spew out attacks on the Con-Dems every few days without damaging political discourse in this country. In fact, such a programme would positively improve British politics, if only because Balls would be excised from it. Binning Balls would be lancing a festering wart on the face of British politics.

No, what does bother me is the increasing use of the word "ideological" in relation to the government's spending cuts. Put simply, there is nothing ideological about these cuts; they are basic economics. The Labour government spent too much, the new government has to spend less - therefore it has to cut spending.

That's not to say that there is anything wrong with ideological attacks on the size of the state and state spending. In fact, I'd love it if the government was being ideological. It would make a welcome change from the bland technocratic government that we have had to endure in this country since 1997. To actually have a government doing something because they believe in it rather than to get good headlines or because they have no choice would be a welcome fucking change, quite frankly.

Using the term "ideological" in the way the quote above does is to run the risk of turning it into an insult - which would be beyond stupid, even for a witless toad like Balls. Surely the reason why people get into politics and join a political party is because of ideology? Politics should be ideological, and if the main parties actually remembered the ideologies they are meant to believe in then politics in this country would be one hell of a lot more interesting than the beyond bland bullshit and empty posturing that had now been substituted for political debate.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

Against the Progressive

In some respects, we're all political progressives. After all, only the morbidly depressed or those who are paranoid and reactionary don't want to make some sort of progress towards what they believe is right politically. No, the concept of progression in politics is not something I object to in principle. What really does bother me is what has come to be defined as "progressive" within politics.

Rather like the word "liberal" in US politics, the term "progressive" here in the UK has been bastardised and corrupted for reasons of political expediency. The left have taken the term progressive and tried to make it synonymous with their own views. It is easy to see why. By claiming they are progressive, they simultaneously create the idea that they are the future and those who oppose them are, almost by definition, regressive.

Yet it is worth interrogating exactly what these people mean by "progressive". What, exactly, is making progress? Let's look at an example of the progressive in action - the oft-floated idea of a progressive tax. What makes a tax "progressive" in the bastardised sense of the word? It is if (a) some people pay more tax than others and (b) more money overall is taken from the people in the form of tax. So what is making progress here? The size of the state, the coffers of the state, and the state's control over its people. Which is actually what progressive politics is actually about - the progression, or rather the growth, of the state. The bastardised definition of progressive is statism, pure and simple.

Which is why, for me and many others, what is defined by many as "progressive politics" is actually fundamentally regressive. Progressive politics works to extend the scope of the state. As such, it works to restrict freedom, making it fundamentally illiberal and against freedom. For me, if politics is to be progressive, then it needs to be about maximising freedom. Those who call themselves progressives stand for the opposite with their innate and seemingly unquestioning reverence for the state and for state control.

Part of me wants to try to reclaim the word "progressive" - to try to make it about freedom again, to make it genuinely radical and actually progressive in a meaningful way. However, that is never going to happen. The word progressive has been bastardised, it has been debased, and I think it is beyond reclamation. Instead, I'll make this pledge. Any party who uses progressive as part of their election rhetoric, or who claims to be progressive, will not get my vote. The progressive as we understand it today is fundamentally regressive to liberty, and as such should be utterly rejected by anyone calling themselves a Libertarian.

Labels: , , ,