Monday, April 18, 2011

Towards a Libertarian Union?

Ok, so, following on from my pessimistic post from the other day, what next for UK libertarians? I’m not going to rehash my arguments about why I think LPUK is screwed. What I will point out is this – the members of and advocates for the party who approach a realistic position are those who, like me, would argue that any real success for that party lies in the distant future. And given the constant encroach of statism and its advocates, the question is pertinent – what do libertarians do while waiting for LPUK to get up and running/do if the party disappears?

We can find a clue in the Rally Against Debt. A grassroots campaign started by two UKIP members has grown massively in a very short space of time. Indeed, its growth is something that LPUK could, and perhaps should, be jealous of. Why has it been so successful? In part, it is about topicality. Debts and spending cuts are at the heart of the debate raging in British politics today. But there is another reason. The rally against debt is not party political, and thus it is not exclusive. It can attract people from the Tories, the Liberal Democrats, UKIP, LPUK and independents. Whereas a political party can only really attract those with no other party affiliation, or an affiliation that they are happy to sacrifice. That automatically limits its potential. So topicality and being inclusive rather than exclusive. What sort of organisation could allow for that?

It occurs to me that some sort of Union might be the way forward (or Federation, for those right-wingers who can’t cope with the idea of Unions). An organisation that can offer people membership in tandem with membership of other organisations – just as members of Trade Unions can be (and often are) members of the Labour party. But rather than offering representation in the workplace, this could be an organisation that fights for its members in the pursuit of liberty. As a Federation/Union, it could do things other than fight elections directly. It could offer support to campaigns run by other organisations (like No2ID, the IEA and the Adam Smith Institute) and highlight events like the Rally Against Debt. At the same time, it could run its own campaigns. It could also have spokespersons on crucial issues and topical events – for example, an organisation that might offer Tim Worstall as Economics Spokesperson and Chris Snowdon as Health Spokesperson (or at least debunking the spurious claims of health “experts” spokesperson) would be pretty formidable. And it could do so without demanding they join a particular party. Likewise, it could attempt to attract high-profile libertarian politicians to write for it on occasion.

But where it could be most formidable is through having a dedicated band of volunteers who could work on behalf of libertarian leaning politicians in election campaigns. Politicians like Douglas Carswell, Steve Baker and Dan Hannan. And LPUK, if they ever become credible contenders in elections. On the flipside, it could also campaign against egregiously statist politicians. A host of Libertarian inclined people pounding the streets in Ed Balls' constituency arguing against his re-election could make all the difference, for example. Indeed, the organisation could replicate the influence of the Tea Party in America (albeit without that organisation’s occasional lapses into insanity). Not backing one party or running its own candidates, it could instead offer support to any candidate it perceives to be a champion of liberty.

Of course, it wouldn’t be easily achieved. Getting libertarians is, as numerous people point out, like herding cats. And there would be a need for the organisation to be professional at all times. There’s no point it being a super-swear-blog; candidates should want to be associated with it, rather than embarrassed by it. But a looser organisation than a political party, one more able to choose what battles it fights, might be able to circumvent the inherent anti-small party biases of our political system. A powerful, grassroots pressure group that can make or break candidates in constituencies maybe far more effective than entryism into an existing party or LPUK. The aspiration would be to have a UK based version of the NRA or a major Trade Union (albeit not necessarily with the core beliefs of either). It wouldn’t be easy, but it might just be worth it.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

The Plan, And How It Doesn't Go Far Enough

The Plan: 12 Months To Renew Britain has been greeted by some with a mix of rapt applause and not inconsiderable relief. After all, it represents a couple of Tories actually coming up with some interesting ideas to change Britain for the better. For those people who tire of the risk averse Cameron and the ideological vacuum that makes up his leadership, The Plan makes for happy reading. It shows that there are some Tories who still have balls and have clear ideas on how they would change this country for the better.

There is little in the book that I could possibly disagree with. Generally speaking, the two authors speak sense and understand that the future of this country is best served by a contraction of the state rather than an expansion of it. Yet for a Libertarian such as myself, what is missing from the book is a true sense of ambition. The reforms proposed are timely, intelligent and interesting. They are also lacking in ideological gravitas and the scope to truly renew Britain. Ultimately, this is a plan to make things a bit different and at the same time improve Britain. It isn't a fundamental challenge to the status quo and the vision used to run Britain today.

Take the issue of taxation. Quite rightly, the authors are keen to make tax an issue, and with their proposals on both VAT and council tax, they seem keen to reduce the tax burden. They also want to make it more transparent, and more open to democratic evaluation. They even quote the Laffer Curve. Yet at no point is the fundamental nature of taxation even questioned, and it is seen as a necessity rather than necessary evil. And reading their proposals on tax left me with a feeling that they wanted to reduce tax, yet don't want to take responsibility for doing so directly. Their policies are a step in the right direction. Unfortunately, it is only a baby step.

Likewise, the book advocates localism. Admirably - particularly for members of a party who will be in power after the next election - they wish to reduce the size and the scope of central government. Yet I get the feeling that this is simply about the transfer of power from one government body to another. Yeah, they do talk about reducing the size of the state. Again, though, they don't go anywhere near far enough with their rhetoric or their proposals. They are right to challenge Central Government, and right to point out the inefficiencies inherent in having a centralised government. Where they drop the ball is in failing to fundamentally address the issue of how much government control we actually want or need in this country. To talk of localism acts a smokescreen for the real problem - which is dealing with balance of power between state and personal control. A balance that at the moment is hopelessly and depressingly in the favour of the state.

As always, it is optimistic to look to the Tories to be Libertarian. Carswell and Hannan are Tory radicals, but they are still Tories. As great as some of their solutions are, they will always be limited by the party they are in. The Tories are not Libertarian, their policies are not Libertarian, and their party is not suitable for Libertarians. These radicals are only radical because they are in the Tory party. And their ideas are only innovative because they exist within the Cameron's neutered, PR driven, post-Blairite Tory party.

Congratulations to Mr Hannan and Mr Carswell for offering the Tories some real policies. It is just a shame that they don't go far enough, in my opinion. And the bitter irony is that whilst I'll criticise them for not going far enough, they are clearly too radical for Hannan and Carswell's own party. Because whilst Cameron may play lip service to their ideas with a primary in Totnes, his stance remains a long way off embracing their far more crucial policies on the NHS or on Europe.

The Plan is an admirable if muted call to arms from two members of a political party not ready to consider their ideas at the moment. To those whose horizons have been limited by the post-Blairite consensus, The Plan may well be a radical document. For me, the true radicalism comes when you are willing to fundamentally redress the balance between state and individual, and come down firmly in the favour of the latter. And The Plan just doesn't do that.

Labels: , , ,