Saturday, October 22, 2011

The Sarah Jane Adventures: The Man Who Never Was

It would take a particularly sour person not to acknowledge that The Man Who Never Was as anything other than fantastically entertaining. It certainly brought a smile to my face as I watched a story that spoofed tablet computers, had James Dreyfus playing a human version of the Master (replete with middle-aged spread), created the portmanteau word Clani and has a surprisingly adult joke in response to the command (delivered by dog whistle, natch) "Grab Harrison's pen". The Skullions - a classic example of an alien species designed to look monstrous but who actually represent the good guys against the real humanoid monsters - also managed to be quite sweet in a strange way and added a certain poignancy to the story. Although, despite the overall humourous and energetic feel to the story, this one could not help but be poignant.

Because that's it for The Sarah Jane Adventures. There's no more. The show is gone. And not because it was struggling to be good, or struggling with the ratings. It wasn't cancelled. It is over because of the death of its star. And if the fact that Elisabeth Sladen may well have been dying as the recorded not just these two episodes but all the ones in this shortened season makes the whole even more poignant; not that you could tell from Sladen's performance, though. Sarah Jane Smith remains the same character she has throughout the whole series, and not just this season. Looking at her performance here - and the energy of her fellow actors and indeed the whole show - this doesn't feel like an ending. It feels like a series that can and should go on an on. It is tragic, really, that it can't.

Perhaps understandably, the show doesn't really stress the fact that is is the end. There is no The End of Time attempts at tear-jerking attempts here. Indeed it doesn't really feel like an ending; the final caption was "And the story goes on... forever". Of course, it can't. At least not on our screens. But it can in books, in fan fiction, and in the imagination of what I would imagine are thousands of children this show has inspired. And that's why, the ending, voiceover, caption and all, is pretty much perfect. It reminds me of the ending to Survival all those years ago; it references the fact that the show is over as a TV programme, but leaves the story open for those who might want to think about what happens next to Sarah Jane, Luke, Sky and the unrequited love (or at the very least affection combined with a healthy dose of attraction) between Clani. Good. Fine. That's the way it should be. The show is over; the story goes on.

Had you told me prior to seeing the first episode over half a decade ago that I would have noticed, let alone cared to the point of writing a slightly maudlin post about, the demise of this show I would have rolled my eyes at you. The very fact that I do care is tribute to the efforts not just Elisabeth Sladen, but to everyone involved in the show. They managed to turn a spin-off show into a classic in its own right. Good on all of you, and as it ends as a TV programme, here's to The Sarah Jane Adventures.

Labels: , , ,

3 Comments:

At 9:42 pm , Blogger liminalD said...

Hi there, just found your blog and have been enjoying going back through and reading past posts, Who-related and otherwise.

I enjoyed this serial but I found it really difficult to watch (as I have most of this most recent series), knowing that Lis Sladen was in the final stages of her terminal illness as she filmed it. Little things just make me really desperately sad, like when Sarah Jane runs and you can kinda tell that Lis was finding it painful. I agree that it was a really satisfactory and appropriate ending to the show, though, and I'll miss it - in many ways it was more faithful to the legacy of Classic Who than even the revived Doctor Who itself.

Cheers,

D.

 
At 1:51 am , Anonymous Anonymous said...

I had similar feelings re the poss of Lis filming this whilst battling cancer. It was thus a huge relief to read in the Afterword to her autobiography that in fact she wasn't diagnosed until last February, and the main symptom by then was tiredness - and judging from Lis's tone throughout the bio, she'd probably have just put that down to getting older. But it was a comfort to know that she didn't film those scenes knowing they'd be her last. I'm also really glad that the 'Goodbye' story was placed at the end of S4 - it's still incredibly poignant to watch, but less heartbreaking that it would be if it'd turned up in S5.

 
At 1:37 am , Anonymous Ashleighii Rome said...

Hi.
this was very factual. You are really talented (I still don't know what libel means though.) Also, why would people be robots? Plus, if the robot was good enough to be used for this, it would be able to work out what it said wouldn't it? Mr Smith would've been able to do it. I'll really miss The Sarah Jane Adventures though. RIP Elizabeth Sladen. xxxx
From ASHLEIGHII ROME.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home